If you are looking for the perfect Waterproof pencil Eyeliner that will not smudge and give you raccoon eyes, well this is it!! A fellow makeup artist reccommended this product to me and I figured I would give it a try. After all, it was less than $10!!! It is a very soft pencil that will stay where you put it! I fell in love with these eyeliners. In the picture above, I used the pencil under her eye, and smudged it out before it dried. I then put green eyeshadow over it to soften it. Their site is www.lorealparisusa.com